Labour has cravenly capitulated to all the demands for savage cuts

Winning the Presidential and Dublin West By elections was hailed as a great day for the Labour Party. While these victories undoubtedly took some of the pressure off the party and its leader, Eamon Gilmore, a sober assessment will conclude that these amount to a small upward blip on a graph that will soon be seen to be on a consistent downward trajectory.

Winning the Presidential and Dublin West By elections was hailed as a great day for the Labour Party. While these victories undoubtedly took some of the pressure off the party and its leader, Eamon Gilmore, a sober assessment will conclude that these amount to a small upward blip on a graph that will soon be seen to be on a consistent downward trajectory.

In Dublin West, Labour’s first preference vote was down 4.5% on last February’s general election. This shows the beginning of a disappointment with the Labour Party nationally which made strong promises in the election campaign about standing up to the agencies promoting austerity such as the European Central Bank.  However since then Labour has cravenly capitulated to all the demands for savage cuts in the living standards of ordinary people and in public services while standing over the payment of billions to the gambling bondholders in Anglo Irish Bank and elsewhere.

On 6 December another budget of swingeing cuts will be introduced by Fine Gael and Labour, to be followed quickly by demands on each home for the payment of a Household Tax, followed some time later by demands for water charges. These new burdens on the shoulders of the ordinary worker or unemployed person will provoke great anger. That will quickly be reflected in how Labour in government is seen.

Whereas up to now the Coalition has attempted to shield itself from all criticism of its economic policies by blaming every problem on fourteen years of rule by Fianna Fail, that will be no longer possible. In the Budget it will be seen that this is a deliberate decision by the government to continue where Fianna Fail and the Greens left off, with the ruinous policy of austerity which is having such a disastrous deflationary effect on the economy.

On his first day in the Dail, Labour’s new TD for Dublin West, Patrick Nulty, was faced with the grim reality of Labour’s role. Because he had spoken at a party conference against Labour participation in Coalition with Fine Gael, he was labelled in some sections  of the media as a “rebel”.  In terms of the Dail, however, his “rebellion” must rank  as the shortest lived in its history.

Nulty was in the Chamber for no more than fifteen minutes when he voted against giving the elected members of the Dail time for a debate and a vote on the payment later that day of €700 million to an assortment of unsecured speculators, a burden that must be met by the taxpayers. He was then paraded on the plinth in front of the Dail in the company of Gilmore and the Minister for (the lack of) Social Protection and promised faithfully to vote with the government.

The election of Michael D Higgins to the Presidency cannot be seen either as a major achievement for Labour or an affirmation of its role in government. Michael D was overshadowed throughout the campaign by, at different times, two independent candidates, Senator David Norris and former Fianna Fail activist Sean Gallagher posing as an outsider.  It was quite clear Higgins was going to be defeated until Gallagher was exposed almost at the eleventh hour as another former tout for financial donations from business to Fianna Fail.

The days when Michael D Higgins was a radical left force in the Labour Party are long gone. Like the soft left in general he capitulated to the right in the party, participating in both a Fianna Fail and Fine Gael dominated government in the nineties. On a few occasions during the campaign he made veiled and vague criticisms of the capitalist markets. As the crisis intensifies, it is not ruled out that he might create some controversy by making some criticism of the injustices of austerity but if so he would be in the contradictory situation that it will be his former colleagues in the Dail who will be wielding the axe.

Total
0
Shares
Previous Article

Gaza Flotilla: Irish activists re-imprisoned just before flight home

Next Article

The truth about Ireland’s super-rich

Related Posts
Read More

Austerity 2013 must be met with mass organised resistance

As another year draws to an end and the next appears on the horizon, social and political activists will try to analyse the significance of what has passed and sketch the rough contours of what lies ahead. The truth is that, while 2013 will no doubt bring surprises, the main economic and political developments will trace their roots to what has been sown and society will reap accordingly. Unfortunately that means, not healthy new shoots signalling a significant renewal, but a continuation of the stunted features to which we have sadly become accustomed though not reconciled.

Joe Higgins: My take on the election

So how does an election candidate feel after a gruelling campaign followed by a twenty one hour count that goes on until the cold light of dawn brightens into the full light of day?
Like a garment that has been churned overlong in an industrial washing machine, with periodic bouts of intense spin drying, and after a final rinse and spin, comes to a shuddering halt in a drained and shrunken condition. And that is when one has emerged successfully!