Elite’s chorus of approval for IMF is out of tune with ordinary people

Media reporting on the Red C poll published last Friday largely concentrated on the levels of support indicated for the political forces contesting the impending General Election.

Media reporting on the Red C poll published last Friday largely concentrated on the levels of support indicated for the political forces contesting the impending General Election.

However, other aspects of the poll which were largely overlooked, yield highly interesting information as to the mood of ordinary people in society in relation to the calamitous crisis in the financial system.

Respondents were asked, “How much do you agree or disagree with the following statement? We should have defaulted on loans rather than bring in the IMF and EU.” 27% replied, “Don’t Know”, 28% disagreed but an astounding 45% agreed.

I say astounding because this view flies in the face of the huge weight of propaganda in most establishment media over the last two years and in the face of the political and economic establishment also. The chorus of unanimity from these sources is to the effect that there is no alternative but to transfer tens of billions of bad, private gambling debts of international and Irish speculators, bankers and developers onto the shoulders of the Irish taxpayers. Yet 72% of these taxpayers are either opposed or not convinced by this propaganda.

This result shows as well that the main establishment parties are not in tune with the majority in society on this. Aggregate support in the poll for Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, the Labour Party and the Greens amounts to 74%. Unfortunately, the poll didn’t have a breakdown on the proportion of intending voters for these parties who reject being held responsible for the speculators’ losses.

Nevertheless, it is clear that the political establishment is away behind the majority of the population in their decision to implement the diktats of the financial markets. We had a similar scenario of the main parties being out of touch in the first votes in the referenda on the Nice and Lisbon Treaties.

This means that a very real debate can take place during the General Election campaign. All the relevant political parties must be forced to justify why they support weighing down this generation and the next with private debts for which they bear no responsibility. They must justify why they are prepared to inflict disastrous cuts in public services which will debilitate those services as already seen in the area of Health. And why they would inflict swingeing attacks on the living standards of workers and those dependent on social welfare while ploughing society’s resources into the bellies of the financial sharks.

Another instance of the kind of burden which people will be increasingly saddled with is evident from leaks concerning what will be in the Finance Bill due to be published on 20 January . It’s said to provide for a new “site property tax”. We will label it as a “Home Tax” instead, designed to lay the basis for squeezing more from the bulk of low and average income earners.

This new tax is tipped to start at an initial figure of €100 in 2012. The impression will be attempted to be given that this is just a relatively small contribution which each householder should make because, of course, “we are all in this together.” This will fool nobody as it will be immediately seen as the thin end of the wedge leading to rapid increases in subsequent years until it becomes a further harsh burden on society.

The 45% of the population indicated as opposed to paying off the speculators’ bad debts will see this new home tax as another instalment in that project. This will intensify resistance in society to the proposed new imposition. A mass boycott of this new tax is inevitable which will pitch the mass of taxpayers against any new government elected in March that attempts to implement it.

Incidentally, it is unfortunate that the Red C poll did not include the new United Left Alliance as a distinct grouping in the poll. Because of this we can only guess what proportion of the 12% pledged to vote independent intend to support Left candidates. However an interesting result emerges in the regional breakdown of the poll.

In the Dublin Region, “independents” are showing at 15%, significantly ahead of Sinn Fein at 11%. The bulk of candidates in Dublin who are classed currently in the “independent” sector by polling organisations, will in fact be from the United Left Alliance, the new grouping of the bigger Left organisations. This suggests a significant support for Left candidates in the capital.

And the answer to the question on whether a default should have taken placed suggests that those candidates who reject the policy of beggaring society to bail out speculators reflect far more closely the attitudes of a huge swathe of the electorate. It is a pity that the polling organisations haven’t explored this phenomenon in greater detail.

Previous Article

General Election Challenge of United Left Alliance Strengthens

Next Article

Statement by the family of Susie Long

Related Posts
Read More

A socialist voice joins Seattle City Council

Who would have imagined that in a major American city, at a post election inauguration ceremony attended by 1,000 people, a new, directly elected Mayor and other members of the City Council would be completely eclipsed by the response of the attendance to a Socialist Councillor? That was the situation in Seattle on 6 January. Socialist Alternative Councillor Kshama Sawant, in her speech, roundly denounced the problems which ‘crisis ridden capitalism’ causes for working class people, called for workers to organise, for a new party of the working class as an alternative to the Republican and Democratic Party politicians and for socialist change.
Read More

Child abuse – Irelands’ gulags

By Joe Higgins

Mary Raftery’s documentary, States of Fear, which gave rise to the Child Abuse Commission was first broadcast just over ten years ago, on Tuesday night, 27th April 1999. It was a shocking story, powerfully told but what happened the next morning in the Dail cast an interesting light on the ‘states of consciousness’ of the main political parties about the seriousness of what it had unearthed.

Labour – No Alternative

AGAINST THE background of the developing crisis in the Irish economy, the Labour Party continues to posture as a party that fights in the interests of working people. At its recent national Conference, Party Leader Eamon Gilmore  several times referred to "crony capitalism" which had brought the country to the "edge of disaster". He demanded an economy "where economic activity is primarily to serve the needs of people and where people are no longer slaves of the market".

The Labour Party now feels comfortable in naming capitalism and the market as responsible for the crisis because this is commonly referred to in the Irish and international media. However just as in that same media establishment, there is no question of the Labour Party identifying socialism as the solution to this crisis. In fact the Labour Party supports the same capitalist market but merely wants it a bit more regulated.