Debenhams strikers won’t settle for peanuts

By Michael O’Brien

No sooner were the Debenhams shop stewards given the gist of a proposed settlement to their struggle for a just redundancy from the Mandate General Secretary, Gerry Light, than it was leaked into the media with a positive spin and additional details that were not even presented to the workers.

Debenhams workers described how relatives and friends began texting them congratulations. However this was not an occasion for celebration. The reality is that, whereas the fight is over two week enhanced redundancy on top of the statutory minimum – which for all the workers would come to a grand total of some €13 million – all that is being offered is a paltry €1 million which would average at a mere €1,200 per worker.

Insulting offer rejected

Had the Debenhams shop stewards been permitted to participate in the contact with the liquidator from the outset the whole month of August would not have been wasted discussing a derisory sum. The first reaction of the shop stewards instead would have been to tell the liquidator to put a zero at the end of that €1 million and then start talking.

The truth is that the €1 million being promised would be dwarfed by the amount set aside for the business creditors and the Revenue. Mandate’s leadership want to move with haste to a ballot of the members. The custom and practice of the shop stewards deciding if an offer is worthy of a ballot has been set aside. They are banking on the fact that a majority of the Debenhams workers have not actively participated in the pickets and are more likely to accept the deal.

However, the fact that they did not participate actively in the struggle is something for which Mandate have to take a share of the blame. 97% of members voted for action in May but Mandate failed to articulate a strategy for struggle. Instead it was left to shop stewards to take the initiative and activate as many of the members as possible. The fact that rank and file initiative got some 200 plus workers consistently active in the struggle over five months is remarkable.

A better deal is possible

Subsequent to the media leak the shop stewards have been in overdrive correcting the perception. Their demand that this deal not go to ballot was absolutely correct. The many interviews done by shop stewards and particularly the occupations of the stores in Henry Street Dublin (albeit short-lived) and Patrick Street Cork brought it home to everybody that the deal was unworthy of a ballot. Mandate were let off the hook when KPMG withdrew the offer. 

However by offering something outside the statutory minimum an important principal has been conceded. New tenants are due to move into a number of the store spaces in October so matters are set to come to a head one way or another. The occupations and the massive public support have injected fresh energy into the struggle. Pressure now needs to be heaped onto the government, and Fianna Fáil in particular, to instruct KPMG to make a proper offer.

Previous Article

Review: A Hero's Death by Fontaines D.C.

Next Article

Support Premier Periclase workers on strike

Related Posts

CPSU mobilises members to defeat levy

By Denis Keane, CPSU Executive

THE ANNOUNCEMENT of a “pension levy" on public sector workers has been met with a wave of anger by civil service and public sector workers. The reality for public sector workers the majority of whom earn €35,000 per annum or less, is that far from being overpaid, they are already struggling. To quote David Begg, the difference this levy will make to these workers is "the difference between existing and not existing".

Waterford Crystal – Nationalisation was the only option

By Cillian Gillespie and Stephen Boyd

AN EIGHT week long occupation of Waterford Crystal ended after the workforce reluctantly voted to accept a "deal". One worker at the end of the four hour long meeting said that he felt the deal was "like a gun to the head" of the workforce.

There were 708 people working in Waterford Crystal, now there will be only 176 jobs some of them are only guaranteed for six months. The so-called redundancy fund is a miserly €10 million to be divided between more than 800 workers and ex-workers. The workers’ pensions (affecting 1,800 people) are still in a mess and the fund is €120 million short.

Read More

GAME over? Full support to GAME workers’ occupation

GAME Stores suddenly announced on Monday  the closure of all 14 of their stores in Ireland, resulting in 121 workers losing their jobs without warning. Many of the workers have provided considerable years of service to the games retailer. The workers have now courageously decided to sit-in 13 of the stores across the country, demanding  their back pay and other money their owed.